Comparison of dialysis methods

Both methods of dialysis are equally effective. There are differences, however. Haemodialysis, for instance, works more quickly than peritoneal dialysis, and so only has to be done in short sessions. Peritoneal dialysis needs to be performed every day. The table below summarises the differences.

Peritoneal dialysis Unit haemodialysis Home haemodialysis

Can do dialysis at home Yes No Yes

Can arrange dialysis sessions at convenient times Yes No Yes

Can easily get to know other patients and see them on a regular basis at unit No Yes No

Need to have equiptment/supplies at home Yes No Yes

Requires a special diet and a fluid allowance Yes Yes Yes

Can participate in most sports and activities Yes Yes Yes

Can carry out full day-time activity (e.g. work or school Yes Sometimes Yes

A member of family/partner needs to be involved No No Yes

Can travel Yes. Delivery of supplies to most holiday destinations is easy. Some notice is required. Yes. Prior arrangements must be made well in advance to find HD facilities at destination. Yes. Prior arrangements must be made well in advance to find HD facilities at destination.

May 1, 2006

Next: Fluid Balance